Reroofing vs. Roof Replacement: Which is Best?

Roofing is a great way to protect the house from adverse weather changes that affect its environment from things like polluted air to heavy rain/snowfall. This leads us to believe that it is essential to choose quality materials and services to keep up the security of your roofing. However, roofing maintenance is not a once and done experience, which calls for regular maintenance to keep up with quality.

As a homeowner’s roofing shows signs of wear-and-tear, the most debated decision comes: Reroof vs. New Roof. There is no specific answer to this, as it depends on the roofing condition, when it was installed, the scope for restoration, and other factors. Do not burn out with stress. We will end the most striking debate and help you make the right choice. Keep reading to explore the best choice.

What Is Re-Roofing?

Re-roofing, also known as roof restoration, involves installing roofing shingles to an existing roof. When re-roofing to your existing roofing shingles, you can enhance your roof appearance, providing an added layer of protection to the roof.

The importance behind re-roofing is to invest in the appearance of a roof and avoid leaking. This is an affordable, yet temporary, solution for homeowners to repair their roofs quickly.

When Is The Right Time For Re-Roofing?

There are various situations where re-roofing comes into play. The following are signs that show that it may be necessary:

  • Appearance Issues: If your roof begins to wear out, but still is well intact in shape, re-roofing can be the ideal choice to bring it back to life and boost performance.
  • Leaks or Minor Damage: The re-roofing of a house is an excellent option for removing leaks or minor damage without needing to replace the whole roof.

What Is Roof Replacement?

Replacement of the roof involves removing and replacing all the shingles with new ones. It involves covering the surface with a waterproof layer or material to provide sustainable protection against the elements. Ensure the underlying layer is adequately installed before installing new shingles on a roof for the next 15-20 years.

It can be more expensive to replace a full roof rather than to replace or add new shingles. Replacement of your entire roof can address structural problems and extend its lifespan considerably. Investing in this kind of repair will allow you to resolve any current issues with your roof, instead of just covering it up with a reroof. When you choose the best roofing company, you can successfully implement roofing replacement.

When Is It Ideal To Replace A Roof?

Re-roofing may not be the best option, always. Roofing replacement is ideal to drive more value from the roof and protect your house. The following are times discuss when it makes sense to replace your roof:

  • End of the Lifecycle of the Roof: If your shingles have reached the end of their lifespan, it may be suitable to go for replacing the roof.
  • Damage to a Large Extent: When a roof suffers major damage, like extensive leaks, rot, or sagging, roof replacement may be the most suitable and permanent option.
  • Several Repairs Are Required: When your roof needs frequent and expensive repairs, you may be better off investing in a new roof.

Essential Differences Between Re-Roofing and Roof Replacement

Re-roofing and Roofing Replacement serve different approaches, but with the ultimate purpose of strengthening the roofing of a house. There are various instances of difficult comparison between choosing to re-roof or a full roof replacement. Let’s explore the differences between Re-Roofing and Roofing Replacement.

Analyze The Condition of Your Roofing

Understanding the roof’s condition is a great way to choose between re-roofing and replacing the roof. Re-roofing is a great choice where you appear to see minor issues with the roofing and still have a long way to go. However, re-roofing can be the most suitable and hassle-free option for homeowners to add to the layer of security and better the home exterior.

Replacing the roof with a new roof can be the choice when your current roofing is a few decades older, and continues to show up with issues and defects too frequently. With roof replacement, you can give a completely new look to your home exterior with new and high-quality roofing.

Re-roofing vs. Roof Replacement Cost

The cost of roofing plays a leading role in helping you choose a suitable roofing company. Re-roofing is the most cost-effective solution, but you cannot always just look at the cost. It can sometimes be the quality and permanent solutions that matter.

If your roofing is new and just a few years old, re-roofing can be an ideal choice. Otherwise, you will have to face the headache of restoration every season, leading to expensive measures, and might ruin your house environment.

Although roof replacement can be considered costly compared to re-roofing, it offers a permanent solution with a guarantee to last longer. With roof replacement, you will get the value for your money.

Timeframe To Complete The Work

Re-roofing doesn’t take long to restore to a new condition. Restoration usually involves adding a layer of roofing shingles to the existing roof rather than a complete tear-off.

In contrast, a roof replacement takes longer since it involves replacing the entire roof. This means the on-site contractors will replace the previous roofing with new roofing solutions. As a result, you will enjoy the long-lasting effect and not have to fear any sudden weather changes.

Long Term Solution

Re-roofing, also known as restoration, is a temporary or alternative solution to damaged roofs. The roof is refined by adding a new layer of roofing, or you can say, improving the lifespan of the existing roofing. Hence, it is a short-term solution.

Roof replacement as a whole is a permanent solution to your damaged roofing . With the perfect use of professional techniques and quality materials, roof replacement allows homeowners to enjoy peace of mind with its capabilities to resist poor weather conditions.


At the end of the day, choosing between re-roofing and a completely new roof should be based on its current condition and needs. Re-roofing can be the temporary fix, but roof replacement is the ultimate solution to all your roofing problems.

Advantage Home Exteriors is your ideal choice for executing your roofing solutions. Our dedicated team of exterior repair professionals deliver top-of-the-line roofing services with the best and most affordable materials for your needs. Contact us today, and experience the best residential roofing service from a trusted contractor.